Why we got back in the market
Roman Chuyan, CFA 11/9/2020
Note: this report was sent to our clients on 11/2/2020. Stocks took off like a rocket ship since then.
- Our Equity Model’s outlook for the S&P 500 changed from Neutral to Positive.
- Our Short-Term Risk model gave a Buy signal after a 6% market drop over two weeks.
- Both models now dictate bullish positioning, and we reinvest in the market.
In my recent articles, I wrote that the market “might get interesting” before the election. Our short-term risk model had been giving a Sell signal since early September. We thought that a “resurgence in COVID … or shifts in the election chances could trigger short-term volatility” (October-20th article). That’s what happened. The S&P 500 has plummeted by 6.1% since mid-October, which took its year-to-date gain down to 2.8% (including dividends). Foreign equities dropped by 7.3% YTD, underperforming US by a 10% margin:
US and Foreign Stocks, Year-To-Date
Source: Ycharts, as of 10/30/2020.
While investors got anxious, the latest US economic numbers have shown remarkable strength. Jobless claims dropped to 751,000 last week, their lowest since March. GDP surged by a stunning 33% annualized in Q3-2020, the fastest quarterly economic growth ever. A V-shaped recovery was, in fact, achieved.
As a side note, this also suggests that US investors should sail close to home. Market growth is driven by economic growth in the long run. Our strategies are US-only.
Due to continued improvement in economic factors and to lower market valuation, our Equity Model has now shifted from Neutral Fundamentals to Positive Fundamentals (the left vertical on the chart below) – see Market Outlook for details.In addition, our Short-Term Risk model gave a closing Buy signal. As I explained previously, the two models work in concert. Both models now dictate bullish, risk-on positioning in our strategies. We therefore shift our strategies to their maximum bullish allocations.
Source: Model Capital Management LLC
The resurgence in COVID cases and uncertainty around the presidential election have given investors chills in the past two weeks, but are these real concerns? Our premise at Model Capital is that fundamentals drive markets: they determine the trend. Things like COVID fluctuations and elections create “noise” around the trend – transitory effects that are hard to predict and don’t last. I like to say that the market is bipolar. Anxious right now, investors were exuberant just two weeks ago based on “stimulus.”
Yes, US daily COVID cases hit an all-time high of 91,530 yesterday. Even though this is being hyped by the media, I don’t think that it’s a real concern for the market. Deaths, which are driven by cases but also by therapeutics and other factors, have ticked up only slightly:
It’s difficult to predict the effect of the election. Uncertainty is bad for the market, and – as I wrote to our clients in the past month – it wasn’t previously priced into the market. The 6% two-week drop might have factored in most of the uncertainty. This is good to see. When it’s over (hopefully the night of November 3rd), we might get a relief rally either way.
Let me be clear once again – we at Model Capital continue to follow our systematic, model-based process. Our models have now turned positive and dictate that we get back in the market. The timing is not accidental: the models turned positive in part because of the market’s recent drop. It improved valuation within the Equity model and helped trigger a Buy signal from the Risk model. It’s not always as synchronized because lags and market noise get in the way. So, such just-in-time model signals synchronized with the market’s pullback is good to see, and allows us to buy near the lows of the past three months.
The outlook for the S&P 500 by our fundamentals-based statistical model improved again this month. Improvements in economic factors and lower valuation due to the market drop contributed roughly equally to the improvement in the model. The forecast has now shifted to a “Positive Fundamentals” range above 3%. Combined with the Buy signal by our Short-Term Risk model, this now dictates bullish allocation.